Stop uncontrolled GMM releases!

Nature is not a laboratory

Protect our health and environment.
Reject the release of genetically modified (GM) microorganisms into nature without robust safeguards.

Here is why

Microorganisms are vital to nature and our health

Microbes are the foundation of all life. Diverse communities of microorganisms, known as microbiomes, help maintain the health of humans, plants and animals.

Now, biotechnology developers want to release genetically modified (GM) microbes – including bacteria, fungi, algae and viruses – into these ecosystems. They claim, for example, that GM bacteria can help supply crop plants with nitrogen or break down chemical pollutants.

The EU plans to weaken safety standards

Biotech companies and their European industry associations argue that strict EU regulations are holding them back – even though only a few GM microbial products have been approved elsewhere, and even fewer have succeeded in the marketplace.

The European Commission has adopted these arguments. To make it easier to release GM microbes into the environment, it has proposed dismantling some of the EU’s regulatory safeguards designed to protect people and the environment we all share.

Nature is not a laboratory

Releasing GM microorganisms into the environment is a risky undertaking. Microbes reproduce and spread, and many exchange genetic material across species boundaries. To this day, we still have only a limited understanding of these processes and interactions. How GM microbes and their engineered genetic material will behave remains difficult to predict. Once a GM microbe establishes itself in an open ecosystem, it can persist, spread far beyond the original release site and pass on its modified genetic material – with no possibility of recalling it.

To make matters worse, the Commission’s plans come at a time when artificial intelligence is massively accelerating microbial genome design, making it possible to create new microbes and microbial communities that might be entirely new to nature.

We still have a choice

So far, the EU has not authorised any GM microorganisms for commercial release into the environment. Environmental releases have been limited to experimental purposes and certain medicinal applications, which are subject to separate rules.

We can still decide how – and whether – such releases should happen.

We have seen what happens when risks are downplayed and safeguards come too late: innovations once hailed as progress, such as microplastics and synthetic pesticides, have become a major burden on soils, oceans, and the health of plants, people and animals.

Take action now

No Uncontrolled Release of GM Microorganisms

TO: European and international policymakers

Protect our health and environment. Reject the release of genetically modified (GM) microorganisms into nature without robust safeguards.

WE CALL FOR:

  • Rigorous scientific assessment before any release, and ongoing monitoring after release. No release should be authorised until the risks can be assessed rigorously and independently based on the available knowledge. Long-term monitoring must be mandatory to identify emerging risks, and authorisations must be time-limited in order to allow reassessment as scientific knowledge evolves.
  • Robust protocols for risk assessment and monitoring. Before any environmental release is authorised, rigorous protocols must be in place to evaluate the organisms’ ability to persist, multiply, evolve and spread their genetic traits; their direct, indirect and cumulative effects on other species and ecosystems; and their potential to spread across borders.
  • Full transparency. No release should be authorised unless methods are available to detect GM microorganisms and their genetic modifications. The public must be informed where GM microorganisms are released.
  • National decision-making. Every national or regional government must have the option to ban or restrict environmental releases of GM microorganisms.

No loopholes. No shortcuts. Nature is not a laboratory.

Nature is not a laboratory

Nature is not a laboratory

WHAT IS
THIS ACTUALLY ABOUT?

Microorganisms are tiny living entities such as bacteria, yeasts, fungi, microalgae and viruses. They live everywhere: in soil, water, plants, animals and our own bodies.

GM microorganisms are microorganisms whose genetic material has been changed in a way that does not occur naturally by mating and/or natural recombination. This can be done with older genetic engineering methods or with newer techniques such as CRISPR ("gene editing").

Mostly in closed facilities. For decades, GM bacteria and yeasts have been used in sealed fermentation tanks to produce substances such as insulin or enzymes. These uses fall under separate EU rules on "contained use" and are not the focus of this petition.

This petition is about something new: releasing living GM microbes into the open environment, for example onto fields, into soil or water.

No. We are calling for strong safeguards for GM microbes that are deliberately released into the environment.

This petition is not about the use of GM microbes in contained facilities or in medicines, including vaccines, which are assessed under their own rules.

What we oppose is the weakening of existing safeguards for the environmental release of GM microbes.

The European Commission has proposed new rules for the deliberate release of GM microorganisms under Directive 2001/18/EC as part of its "Biotech Act". The goal is to make it easier and faster to place products on the EU market that contain or consist of GM microorganisms intended for environmental release (European Commission website).

Under the EU’s GMO Directive (Directive 2001/18/EC), genetically modified organisms (GMOs) intended for deliberate release into the environment require authorisation based on a pre-market risk assessment. Applicants must also submit a post-market monitoring plan and an approved detection method. Authorisations are valid for a maximum of 10 years and can only be renewed following a new application and risk assessment.

So far, no GM microorganism has been authorised for commercial release into the environment under the EU’s GMO Directive. The EU has no practical experience with such releases. Nevertheless, the Commission has proposed lowering the Directive’s requirements for GM microorganisms:

  • Unlimited authorisations: authorisations for placing GMMs on the market would no longer be limited to 10 years. The Commission says this would reduce the administrative burden for operators and national competent authorities.
  • Reduced information requirements: information requirements would be “adapted” to take account of the specific characteristics of GMMs, although Directive 2001/18/EC already allows certain flexibility in the information required.
  • Reduced detection requirements: requirements concerning the detection, identification and quantification of GMMs would be adapted where it is “not feasible” to provide an appropriate method. This could limit the capacity to monitor the spread of released GMMs and to detect the transfer of genetic modifications to other organisms within microbial communities.

In addition, the Commission proposes a new category of “low-risk GMMs” that would benefit from a more streamlined authorisation procedure and reduced information requirements. In certain cases, post-market environmental monitoring could also be waived.

To qualify for the ”low risk” category, a GMM would have to meet three conditions: the microorganism would have to be “well-characterised”, it would have to appear on the EU list of microorganisms with a Qualified Presumption of Safety (QPS), and it would have to contain no “genes of concern” that are not already present in the parental organism.

In the EU, it is the European Commission that proposes new legislation. It presented its legislative proposal on GMMs on 16 December 2025 (European Commission website) without any impact assessment or dedicated public consultation.

Both the Council of the EU and the European Parliament need to agree on the legislation. The Council has already adopted its position, largely following the Commission’s proposal (Council press release). The Parliament is expected to vote on its position on 25 November.

Once both institutions have agreed on their positions, they will begin negotiations on the final text. The result must then be formally adopted by both Parliament and Council.

Microbes behave very differently from plants:

  • They multiply fast. Bacteria, for example, can produce many generations in a single day.
  • They swap genes. Many microbes exchange genetic material with other species, a process called horizontal gene transfer. Engineered genes can therefore end up in completely different organisms.
  • They are invisible and mobile. They spread with wind, water, soil, animals and people, across fields and borders.
  • They cannot be recalled. Once a GM microbe has established itself in an open ecosystem, it is extremely difficult, if not impossible, to remove the organism or its modified genes from the environment.

On 28 August 2026, members of ecological science societies from across Europe issued a statement on the Commission's proposal. They warned against lowering safety standards for the environmental release of GM microorganisms and called for microbe-specific environmental risk assessments, long-term monitoring and shorter authorisation periods, among other things (Ecologists’ statement).

On 13 October 2026, 62 researchers, including ecologists and evolutionary biologists, published a statement in Le Monde warning that the proposals could change our relationship with the living world. They called for careful, case-by-case risk assessment and monitoring, as required under current EU law (Le Monde). Their letter is being supported by an increasing number of scientists across Europe.

In the US, GM nitrogen-fixing bacteria have been used commercially since 2019. In 2023 alone, one company's products were applied to about 2 million hectares (MIT Technology Review). Also in the US, a self-spreading, super-competing GM probiotic is available for sale.

But “no problems reported” is not the same as “proven safe”. Effects may take years to become apparent and can be difficult to measure. That is precisely why post-release monitoring and regular reassessment matter – measures that the Commission is proposing to remove.

Given the risks and uncertainties involved in the environmental release of GM microbes, current rules provide important safeguards for the environment and our health. They require a case-by-case risk assessment, environmental monitoring and periodic reassessment in light of new scientific knowledge – exactly what you would expect for living organisms that cannot be recalled once released.

Innovation that stands up to scrutiny should welcome these safeguards, not seek to weaken them. And many of the promised benefits, such as reduced use of synthetic fertilisers, can already be achieved through proven agronomic practices and innovations.

AI is opening pathways to analyse, engineer and even design entirely new microbes. In August 2026, researchers at Stanford University and the Arc Institute published in Science that an AI model had designed complete genomes of viruses that infect bacteria for the first time (research study).

Biosecurity experts warn that governance is not keeping pace with this capability (commentary published alongside the study). Loosening release rules now means opening the door just as entirely new, AI-designed organisms are becoming possible.

We want the EU’s existing safeguards to be maintained. We are calling for

  • Robust scientific assessment before any release, and ongoing monitoring after release. No release should be authorised until the risks can be assessed rigorously and independently based on the available knowledge. Long-term monitoring must be mandatory to identify emerging risks, and approvals must be time-limited in order to allow reassessment as scientific knowledge evolves.
  • Rigorous protocols must be in place to assess the risks and monitor the effects. Before any approval for environmental release, rigorous protocols must be in place to evaluate the organisms’ ability to persist, multiply, evolve and spread their genetic traits; their direct, indirect and cumulative effects on other species and ecosystems; and their potential to spread across borders.
  • A regulatory framework without blind spots. No new technology should escape pre-market evaluation and regulatory oversight simply because it does not fall within established categories.
  • Sign the petition.
  • Share it with friends, family and colleagues. Most people have never heard of this proposal.

NGOs, farmers' associations, businesses and research groups can support the petition, share it with their members and join the campaign. Contact: info@saveourseeds.org

Our Partners

Agrolink
Beyond GM
Biodynamic Federation Demeter
Det Fælles Bedste
Foreningen for Biodynamisk Jordbrug
Frie Bønder – Levende Land
Gegen Nachbau-Gebühren
GMWatch
KBH FF
Association Kokopelli
Landsforeningen for Økosamfund
Make Impact Films
Permakultur Danmark
Self-sustaining Cities
Sito Seeds
Save Our Seeds
Testbiotech